baby s first foot print
Photo by Vidal Balielo Jr. on Pexels.com

In a recent summary decision, the Massachusetts Appeals Court affirmed a Probate and Family Court judge’s refusal to change a young child’s surname from the mother’s alone to a hyphenated combination of both parents’ names.

The case, Julien L. Pham v. Alison R. Allukian (25-P-753), arose after the parents signed a birth certificate giving the child the mother’s surname. Roughly two years later, the father petitioned under G.L. c. 210, § 12 to add his surname via hyphenation. The mother opposed, and after trial the judge denied the request. The Appeals Court found no abuse of discretion.

Under settled Massachusetts law, a petition to change a child’s surname is governed by the best-interests-of-the-child standard. The parent seeking the change bears the burden of proving it would benefit the child. Relevant factors include the effect on the child’s relationships with each parent and other family members, how long the child has used the current name, the child’s age and degree of identification with that name, and any practical difficulties or embarrassment the present or proposed name might cause.

On appeal, the father argued that the standard should be updated for modern family structures and that a hyphenated name should be favored when parents share custody and no harm would result. The court treated the ā€œmodernizationā€ argument as waived because it was not raised at trial and, in any event, rejected it as inconsistent with existing precedent. The court also declined to adopt a presumption favoring hyphenation.

The trial judge had made detailed findings that the Appeals Court accepted as unchallenged. Among them: the mother is strongly attached to her heritage and culture and wants to share a surname with her child; the father’s heritage is already reflected in three of the child’s four names; and, balancing the relevant factors (including the child’s identification with the current surname and the custody arrangement), the proposed change would not further any interest of the child. The Appeals Court emphasized that it will not reweigh evidence when the judge applied the correct standard and reached a reasonable conclusion.

The mother’s request for attorney’s fees and double costs was denied; the court concluded the appeal was not frivolous.

As a Rule 23.0 summary decision, the opinion is directed primarily to the parties, is not circulated to the full court, and may be cited only for its persuasive value, not as binding precedent. It nevertheless illustrates the continued application of the traditional best-interests framework to children’s surname changes in Massachusetts and the substantial deference given to trial judges who carefully apply the governing factors.